Note: I have zero knowledge about music. Will be grateful for any errors that are pointed out. Thanks.Not "learning" music is something I regret a lot. Something I intend to put right someday. But then I guess I never was the musical type when I was a kid.
So anyway, having an interest in music and there being not a lot to choose from, film music occupied -- occupies -- a lot of my "music time". The following clips are two of my favourite pieces of Tamil film music.
But if you're going to hear them, I suggest you get a pair of good headphones/earphones, crank up the volume on the PC and the headphones, and really
listen. The effect is totally lost on speakers.
Now that that little technicality is out of the way, here you go -
7 comments:
interesting comparison!!!
Ah, seems like the list of anonymous commenters on the blog is growing by the day.
So is this who I think it is? :P
It is not me :)
the second anonymous
And I have no idea who this is either!
Have a couple of things to comment upon.
1. "I have zero knowledge about music."
Knowledge isnt a pre requisite to enjoy music. Even an infant relishes lullabies. And your post seems to capture your emotional vicissitudes in tune with the music, rather than a general commentary on the songs.
2.Heard somewhere in some interview,that Ilayaraja sets music only after listening to the situation and brings out his songs after the lyrics have been written.. Well, what I feel when i listen to both rehman and raja, is that raja's music is more in appropos with the storyline.. mahendran,maniratnam,balu mahendra are some directors who in the 80's produced such moving masterpieces...And Raja's music was a powerful asset to their story telling.. Rehman , right from his leo coffee jingle has been a pleasure for the ears.. innovating each time with new sounds that grow on you... But post-rangeela rehman fails to stand in comparison to his own self before that...But one trend , which seems to strike me is that all the numbers for one movie all appear to be different designs woven on the same fabric.. Though the fabric changes each time, but one album is one cuisine...Maybe his inspiration of the season...
My personal favorite for the lyrics and the music is "putham puthu bhoomi vendum" from thriuda thiruda... Brings up a whiff of fresh green pastures every time i hear it...
But the magic rehman wove in roja was sadly missing in movies like kannathil mutham ittal, lagaan, swades etc, inspite of being masterpices in their own right, the later ones didnt scale up to the evergreen starter...
Jus my views, could have been a post, for the sheer length, but then commenting is a lot easier.. :-)...
P.S: My knowledge of formal music is extrodinarily blotched even for my standards...barring a few sporadic forays..
-Soliloquist
the soliloquist
Firstly, thanks for leaving a name :)
Now to your comments -
1. "Knowledge isnt a pre requisite to enjoy music." -- of course, I agree. What I wanetd to make clear was that I'm no guru when it comes to certain technical aspects of music and that I would love it if someone was to help me out there.
2. "And your post seems to capture your emotional vicissitudes in tune with the music, rather than a general commentary on the songs." -- This post was always going to be a very subjective one. See, it's like this. Appreciation of anything can be of an objective or a subjective nature. To appreciate objectively, one needs a certain degree of accomplishment. If one were to see Rahul Dravid play a flick against Shane Warne, a subjective appreciation would be of the beauty and grace of the shot which appeals to the observer. An objective appreciation -- provided one has the depth of knowledge required -- would be of how difficult it is to a) get into position b) counter the turn and c) the skill involved in manipulating one's wrists to time that shot perfectly, because all said and done, irrespective of whether the shot appeals to one personally, it still is a good shot because of a,b and c above.
Since I don't have the depth of knowledge required to "analyse" music, I can only resort to describing personal emotions, a subjective appreciation which need not be shared by everyone else and which cannot stand on its own. And to be fair to me, I have speculated so much in the post that it is anything but objective.
However, that said, I would still be very surprised if those specific pieces of music don't evoke similar sentiments in others.
3. "raja's music is more in appropos with the storyline" -- not sure if I agree with that. I feel both of them are good at "situation songs". To quote recent examples, "nee elai naan mazhai" in Aayutha Ezhuthu said more about the Siddharth-Trisha relationship than did the story. I'm sure I can come up with more. Maybe Rahman hasn't had a chance to work with great directors in tamil and maybe directors just massacre his songs with their videos.
4. "But one trend , which seems to strike me is that all the numbers for one movie all appear to be different designs woven on the same fabric.. Though the fabric changes each time, but one album is one cuisine...Maybe his inspiration of the season..." -- absolutely! I just told a friend something similar recently. How the music of Swades, Lagaan, Bose, Bhagat Singh, RDB are all reflective of their respective movies and how Rahman tries to create an album for a movie. it's almost like he doesn't want to leave a personal stamp on the movies. I think that requires a lot of talent. If you listen to Laggan, the music so easily evokes the ethos of that time. Same with Bose.
4. "My personal favorite for the lyrics and the music is "putham puthu bhoomi vendum" from thriuda thiruda" -- that's a favourite as well. The freshness is unparallelled. And what about "margazhi poovae"? I'm sure Ilayaraja could never have composed a song like that!
Personally I feel A.R.R. is going through a phase of disillusionment with the movie industry. He needs something more to get his genius working I guess.
"Maybe Rahman hasn't had a chance to work with great directors in tamil and maybe directors just massacre his songs with their videos."
So true.... Was absolutely crest fallen when I got see "new york nagaram" on screen... was expecting something more expressive than surya running around with a sullen face and jyothika's maudlin mumbling of the female part (thought that was supposed to blend with the BGM..)
Beats me... The apathy of the directors...
-Soliloquist
Post a Comment